David De Gea: Should have done better with Atalanta’s opening strike, letting Ilicic’s strike go under his body. Did make a smart stop to deny Zapata late on but let the Red Devils down again. 5/10
Eric Bailly: Brilliant block to deny Zapata after Pogba gave away possession in the area. United’s best defender on the night. 7
Raphael Varane: Forced off with an injury just before the break but was struggling with Zapata’s pace and power before it. 5
Harry Maguire: Was caught out playing a high line as Zapata escaped to restore Atalanta’s lead in the second half. Had an uncomfortable night against the powerhouse striker. 5
Aaron Wan-Bisska: Was unable to make the barnstorming runs he did at Spurs as United were forced into a formation change after Varane’s injury. 6
Bruno Fernandes: Brilliant flick to tee-up Ronaldo for United’s equaliser but didn’t have his normal impact on the game. Still surprisingly taken off late on. 6
Scott McTominay: Had his work cut out in the first half with Pogba alongside him instead of Fred. Booked and subbed late on. 6
Paul Pogba: Poor giveaway in his own area almost cost United a second goal in the first half. Workrate questioned again in a midfield two and hauled off on 69 minutes. 5
Luke Shaw: Always an outlet down the left but final ball often let him down. 6
Marcus Rashford: Looked dangerous early on but faded out of the game. Taken off with just over 20 minutes to go. 6
Cristiano Ronaldo: Finished off a brilliant United move just before the break to draw them level and produced a superb volley to rescue a point in stoppage-time. Just sheer class. 9
Substitutes:
Mason Greenwood (on for Varane, 39): Failed to stamp his authority on a game where United’s attack struggled. 5
Nemanja Matic (on for Pogba, 69): Neat and tidy as always but made little impact. 5
Edinson Cavani (on for Rashford, 69): Put himself about as United showed a bit more urgency in the search for an equaliser. 6
Jadon Sancho (on for McTominay, 87): N/A
Donny van de Beek (on for Fernandes, 87): N/A

